Tax Design and
Legislation Branch
Tax Legislation Bulletin Number 98-1, February 1998
The 1997 Ontario Budget announced three important measures relating to the capital tax treatment of financial institutions.
These and other 1997 Budget measures were implemented by The Tax Credits to Create Jobs Act, 1997 (Bill 164), which amended the Corporations Tax Act (CTA) and other provincial statutes. Bill 164 received royal assent on December 18, 1997. The amendments to Part III of the CTA are contained in sections 28 to 41 of Bill 164.
This tax legislation bulletin clarifies various details pertaining to these measures and refers to certain changes from the 1997 Budget that were made in Bill 164. These changes were described in a 1997 Budget Update released by the Ministry of Revenue on November 25, 1997, entitled "Capital Tax Harmonization for Financial Institutions."
This bulletin is intended to be a guide only and does not purport to be a substitute for the legislation or regulations. For precise details, the reader should consult the legislation and corresponding regulations.
Capital Tax Harmonization for Financial Institutions
Temporary Capital Tax Surcharge
Small Business Investment Tax Credit for Financial Institutions
Prior to the capital tax harmonization initiative announced in the 1997 Budget, Ontario's capital tax system provided special rules for certain types of financial institutions: banks, corporations registered under the Loan and Trust Corporations Act, bank mortgage subsidiaries, mortgage investment corporations and credit unions. These corporations were subject to different methods of computing taxable paid-up capital as well as different capital tax rates.
Other corporations carrying on business in the financial services
industry were subject to capital tax as ordinary corporations.
As a
result of harmonization with the federal large corporations tax, financial
institutions will be subject to uniform rules for the computation of adjusted
taxable paid-up capital and will generally be subject to the same capital tax
rates: 0.6% on adjusted taxable paid-up capital of $400 million and less, and
0.9% on adjusted taxable paid-up capital greater than $400 million.
The term "financial institution" is now defined in subsection 58(2) of the CTA. A corporation will generally be a financial institution for Ontario capital tax purposes if the corporation is a financial institution for the purposes of the federal large corporations tax.
The following corporations qualify as financial institutions:
Unlike the federal system, insurance corporations are not included in the definition of financial institution. Insurance corporations do not pay Ontario capital tax, but pay a special premiums tax under Part IV of the CTA.
To recognize the investments that financial institutions make in insurance corporations, insurance corporations will be treated the same as financial institutions for certain purposes.
The 1997 Budget also announced that certain prescribed corporations will be included in the definition of financial institution. It is the Ministry's intention that the following corporations will be prescribed as financial institutions:
A corporation that wishes to be prescribed as a financial institution should apply in writing to the Ministry of Revenue. The request should include a detailed description of the corporation's business, to establish that the corporation acts as a financial intermediary, and a copy of the corporation's latest financial statements.
If the application by a corporation to be prescribed is accepted, it is intended that any related corporations that are prescribed federally as financial institutions for the purposes of the large corporations tax will also be prescribed for Ontario purposes.
Where a corporation makes an application to be prescribed on or before the later of April 30, 1998 and 30 days following the end of the corporation's taxation year that includes May 7, 1997, and the application is accepted, it is intended that the corporation will generally be prescribed to be a financial institution as of May 7, 1997.
Other applications by corporations to be prescribed as financial institutions will be dealt with on a prospective basis. Where the application to be prescribed is accepted, the prescription will generally be effective for the taxation year in which the application is approved.
A request by a corporation to be prescribed should be addressed to the following:
Ministry of Revenue
Corporations Tax Branch
33 King St. West
4th floor
Oshawa,
Ontario
L1H 8H5
Attention: Tax Advisory Section
Tel: 905 433-6513
Fax: (905)
433-6747
A financial institution computes its capital tax liability using its adjusted taxable paid-up capital. The following table illustrates the manner in which a financial institution's adjusted taxable paid-up capital and capital tax liability is determined:
| Computation of a Financial Institution's Adjusted Taxable Paid-up Capital and Capital Tax |
|---|
| Paid-up Capital (S. 62.1(2)) |
| - Investment Allowance (S. 62.1(5)) |
| = Taxable Paid-up Capital (S. 62.1(4)) |
| + 1/3 Canadian Tangible Property (S. 62.1(7), (8)) |
| - $2 Million Capital Deduction (S. 62.1(10)) |
| = Adjusted Taxable Paid-up Capital (S. 62.1(6)) |
| x Capital Tax Rate (S. 66(4)) |
| x Ontario Allocation (S. 66(4)) |
| = Capital Tax Liability |
A financial institution is first required to determine the amount of its paid-up capital under subsection 62.1(2). Its paid-up capital is generally computed in the same manner as its capital is determined under Part I.3 of the Income Tax Act (Canada) and is equal to:
less
Unlike the federal rules, a financial institution will be able to deduct, in computing paid-up capital for Ontario purposes, the amount of any R&D and Ontario New Technology Tax Incentive expenditures that are deductible under Part II of the CTA but that have not been deducted in computing income under that Part.
A financial institution computes its taxable paid-up capital under subsection 62.1(4).
The taxable paid-up capital of a financial institution is the amount of its paid-up capital, less an investment allowance for its investments in the shares or long-term debt of a related financial institution or insurance corporation that has a permanent establishment in Ontario.
Financial institutions may claim an investment allowance, as determined under subsection 62.1(5), in respect of the amount of its investments in the shares or long-term debt of a related financial institution or insurance corporation that has a permanent establishment in Ontario. The amount of the allowance claimed is adjusted upwards or downwards, depending on whether the proportionate business carried on in Ontario by the corporation in which the investment is made is greater or less than the proportionate business carried on in Ontario by the corporation that made the investment.
The investment allowance that a financial institution (Parent) may claim in respect of a particular investment in a related financial institution or insurance corporation (Sub) is determined as follows:
Investment allowance = amount of investment x (% of Sub's business in Ontario ÷% of Parent's business in Ontario)
The percentage of a financial institution's business that is carried on in Ontario is determined in accordance with the existing rules in Part III of Regulation 183 under the CTA that apply to determine the proportion of a financial institution's taxable paid-up capital that is allocated to Ontario.
|
Example 1
$100,000 × 60% / 40% = $150,000 |
A financial institution's adjusted taxable paid-up capital, in respect of which its capital tax is calculated, is determined under subsection 62.1(6).
The adjusted taxable paid-up capital of a financial institution is equal to its taxable paid-up capital:
The amount in respect of a financial institution's tangible property used in Canada that is included in the computation of adjusted taxable paid-up capital is a "specified percentage" of one-third of the amount of its tangible property used in Canada determined in respect of the financial institution under paragraphs 181.3(1)(a) and (b) of the Income Tax Act (Canada).
A corporation's Ontario capital tax liability is based on the proportion of the corporation's taxable paid-up capital used in Ontario to its total taxable paid-up capital. As a result, the amount of the financial institution's tangible property used in Canada will be grossed-up prior to allocation to Ontario in order to ensure that the proper result is achieved after provincial allocation (subsections 62.1(7) and (8)). The mechanism that determines this gross-up is the multiplication of the financial institution's tangible property used in Canada by a "specified percentage."
One-third of this amount (i.e. one-third of the specified percentage of the corporation's tangible property used in Canada) is included in the financial institution's adjusted taxable paid-up capital. This reflects the fact that the capital tax rate applicable to ordinary corporations is one-third of the top rate applicable to financial institutions.
|
Example 2
Ontario - 50%
100% / 80% × $1,000,000 × 1/3 = $416,667
|
Financial institutions are entitled to a $2 million deduction in computing adjusted taxable paid-up capital (subsection 62.1(10)).
A two-tier rate of capital tax applies to financial institutions (subject to the exceptions described below): 0.6% on the first $400 million of adjusted taxable paid-up capital and 0.9% on the amount in excess of $400 million.
The capital tax rate applicable to credit unions is capped at 0.6% and is phased-in over a five-year period (S. 66(6)):
The above capital tax rates for credit unions are prorated for taxation years that straddle the effective dates.
The rate of capital tax payable by a financial institution that is not a deposit-taking institution, and that is not related to a deposit-taking institution, on adjusted taxable paidup capital above $400 million is 0.72%.
Credit unions are subject to the new rules for financial institutions after December 31, 1997.
Other financial institutions that are members of a related group of financial institutions and insurance corporations with taxable capital employed in Canada as determined under Part I.3 of the Income Tax Act (Canada) greater than $10 million are subject to the new rules after May 6, 1997. These financial institutions are required to calculate their capital tax liability for a taxation year straddling May 6, 1997 under two methods: firstly, under the rules in effect before May 7, 1997 and, secondly, under the rules in effect after May 6, 1997. Their liability for capital tax under each of these methods is then prorated, as the case may be, for the number of days in the taxation year before May 7, 1997 and the number of days in the taxation year after May 6, 1997.
Remaining financial institutions will be subject to the new rules for taxation years commencing after May 6, 1997.
The temporary capital tax surcharge, which was first imposed on
large banks in the 1996 Ontario Budget, was extended in the 1997 Budget to all
large deposit-taking financial institutions (other than credit unions). The
surcharge was also extended to October 31, 1998, consistent with the measure
announced in the 1997 Federal Budget.
The surcharge now applies to a
deposit-taking institution's adjusted taxable paid-up capital over $400 million
(subsection 66.1(2)).
A deposit-taking institution is a financial institution that is (subsection 66.1(1.2)):
The small business investment tax credit for financial institutions allows financial institutions to reduce their capital tax liability where they make certain types of investments in small businesses.
As originally announced in the 1996 Ontario Budget, only banks were allowed to reduce their capital tax where they made eligible investments in qualifying small businesses.
The 1997 Ontario Budget announced significant changes to the tax credit.
The remainder of this Bulletin summarizes the operation of the small business investment tax credit for financial institutions.
A financial institution, other than a credit union, may claim the tax credit if it is a member of a related group of financial institutions and insurance corporations that has aggregate adjusted taxable paid-up capital in excess of $400 million. In addition, at least one member of the related group must be a deposit-taking institution, i.e. banks, trust and loan companies and credit unions (subsections 66.1(2) - (3.2)).
A credit unions may also claim the tax credit, regardless of the amount of its adjusted taxable paid-up capital (subsection 66.1(3.3)).
A financial institution may claim the tax credit for an eligible investment made by it (if it is a deposit-taking institution), or by a related deposit-taking institution, insurance corporation, or specified corporation (clause 66.1(4)(a)).
As a result, a financial institution does not itself have to be qualified to make the types of investments that are eligible for the tax credit in order to take advantage of the credit to reduce its capital tax.
The amount of capital tax that a financial institution (other than a credit union) may earn back under the tax credit for a taxation year is the amount of its temporary surcharge plus 20% of its capital tax liability on adjusted taxable paid-up capital over $400 million (subsection 66.1(3.2)).
A credit union may earn back all the capital tax that it pays for a taxation year (subsection 66.1(3.3)).
The amount of capital tax and surcharge that a financial institution can earn back under the credit for a taxation year is called its "eligible tax."
A financial institution may earn back its eligible tax for a taxation year through investments made before the end of the second calendar year following the calendar year in which the taxation year ends (subsections 66.1(3) and (3.1)).
A bank subject to the temporary surcharge announced in the 1996 Budget still has until December 31, 1999 to earn back the amount of its temporary surcharge for the period between May 8, 1996 and May 6, 1997.
An eligible investment for the purposes of the tax credit is (subsection 66.1(4.9):
A patient capital investment is an investment that would have qualified as an eligible investment for the purposes of the tax credit before the changes announced in the 1997 Budget (subsection 66.1(4.14)).
A patient capital investment is defined by regulation to mean a "qualifying share" issued by a qualifying small business corporation and a "qualifying obligation" issued by a qualifying small business or qualifying small business corporation (sections 1 and 5 of CTA Regulation 318/97).
For an investment to qualify as a patient capital investment, the qualifying small business corporation or qualifying small business must use the invested funds in an active business carried on primarily in Ontario and must not use the funds for certain specific purposes that are generally unrelated to the carrying on of an active business (section 6 ofCTA Regulation 318/97).
Where the patient capital investment is a loan to a qualifying sole proprietor, the loan will not be an eligible investment unless the sole proprietor provides certain financial information to the investing bank and undertakes to use the investment for business purposes and to keep business assets separate from personal assets (subsections 5(3) and (4) of CTA Regulation 318/97).
A below-prime loan is a loan made after May 6, 1997 to a qualifying small business or qualifying small business corporation for an amount not exceeding $50,000, provided that the rate of interest payable in respect of the loan is less than the average bank prime rate (subsection 66.1(4.10)).
In addition, the following conditions must be satisfied:
To simplify the due diligence process for financial institutions making below-prime loans, a small business may certify to the lender that the business meets the size test and that the proceeds of the loan will be used for a permitted purpose and will not be used in an prescribed business (subsection 66.1(4.11)).
The CTA regulation for the small business investment tax credit will be amended to include these rules with respect to below-prime loans.
An investment in Class A shares issued by a community small business investment fund corporation in accordance with the Community Small Business Investment Funds Act is an eligible investment.
Ministry of Revenue
Manager, Business
Investment Plans Section
Tax Credits and Grants Branch
33 King
St. W.
Oshawa, Ont.
L1H 8H5
Tel.: 1 800 263-7466; Fax: (905)
436-4496
Several tax credit rates apply in respect of patient capital investments, depending on both the size of the investment and the size of the business in which the investment is made.
The tax credit rates applicable to patient capital investments are as follows (subsection 66.1(4.8)):
| Credit Rate | Size of Investment | Size of Business |
|---|---|---|
| 75% |
Investments under $50,000 Rate is phased out to 20% for investments between $50,000 and $100,000. The total amount of the financial institution's eligible investments in the small business must not exceed $100,000. |
Rate phased out to 20% where between $500,000 and $750,000. Also phased out to zero where group assets or revenue are between $1 million and $5 million. |
| 20% |
Investments between $100,000 and $250,000. Rate is phased out to 10% for investments between $250,000 and $1 million. |
Rate is phased out to zero where group assets or revenue are between $1 million and $5 million. |
| 10% | Investments above $1 million, with no cap. | Rate is phased out to zero where group assets or revenue are between $1 million and $5 million. |
A 4% credit is available for below-prime loans made by a financial institution, calculated annually in respect of the average outstanding balance of the loan for each year (subsection 66.1(4.3)).
Unlike the tax credit claimed by a financial institution for a patient capital investment, the credit claimed by a financial institution for a below-prime loan will not be recaptured where the loan is considered to be disposed of under the rules contained in the regulations.
|
Example 3
The tax credit that FI#1 can claim in 1998 for each below-prime loan is determined as follows:
|
An investment by a financial institution in a corporation registered as a Community Small Business Investment Fund Corporation (CSBIF) under the Community Small Business Investment Funds Act qualifies for a tax credit of up to 60%.
The 60% credit is available as follows: 30% for the taxation year in which the financial institution invests in Class A shares of the CSBIF and 30% in a taxation year to the extent that the CSBIF re-invests the amount of the financial institution's investment in eligible investments as defined in the Community Small Business Investment Funds Act (subsections 66.1(4.5) to (4.7) of the CTA). The up-front credit may be claimed for investments made after May 6, 1997 and before January 1, 1999.
|
Example 4 On July 1, 1998, FI#1 acquires Class A shares from a CSBIF for the amount of $300,000. On July 1, 1999, the CSBIF reinvests $200,000 of the amount invested by FI#1 in eligible investments in small businesses in accordance with the CSBIF Act. The Minister allows FI#1's application for a tax credit in respect of its investment in the CSBIF. FI#1's year-end is Dec. 31. The tax credit that FI#1 can claim in its 1998 taxation year is: $300,000 × 30% = $90,000 The tax credit that FI#1 can claim in its 1999 taxation year is: $200,000 × 30% = $60,000 |
A financial institution may deduct in computing its tax under Part III of the CTA for a taxation year the lesser of three amounts (subsection 66.1(2)):
The tax earn-back account of a financial institution for a taxation year refers to the amount of capital tax paid by the financial institution for the taxation year and the three previous taxation years that can be earned back in the taxation year under the tax credit, i.e. the amount of eligible tax paid by the financial institution for those years less the amount of that tax that the financial institution has already earned back under the credit.
A financial institution's tax earn-back account for a taxation year (ss. 66.1(3), (4)) is the amount by which:
A financial institution must therefore keep records of the amount of eligible tax for a particular year that it earns back in the year and in the three subsequent years.
|
Example 5 FI#1 wants to determine the amount of its tax earn-back account for the 2002 taxation year. Its year-end is October 31. FI#1's eligible tax for 2002 and the three preceding taxation years is as follows: 2002 - $500,000 FI#1 earned back all of its eligible tax for the 1999 taxation year through eligible investments made in the 2001 taxation year. FI#1 has not earned back any other part of its eligible tax. FI#1's tax earn-back account for the 2002 taxation year is the following amount: $500,000 + $500,000 + $450,000 + $350,000 - $350,000 = $1,450,000 |
A financial institution's small business investment tax credit account is effectively the aggregate amount of unclaimed tax credits for eligible investments made by the financial institution or a related corporation and allocated to the financial institution.
The small business investment tax credit account of a financial institution for a taxation year (subsection 66.1(4)) is the total of:
less
|
Example 6 FI#1 wants to determine the amount of its small business investment tax credit account for the 2002 taxation year. FI#1 is a deposit-taking institution. FI#1 is related to one other corporation (FI#2), that is also a financial institution that is a deposit-taking institution. The total of all tax credit amounts in respect of eligible investments made by FI#1 and FI#2 before the end of the 2002 taxation year that are allocated to FI#1 is $5,000,000. FI#1 has claimed for prior taxation years small business investment tax credits in the amount of $2,000,000. FI#1 and FI#2 have not disposed of any patient capital
investments. FI#1 has not made any tax credit repayments under subsection
66.1(12) of the CTA. $5,000,000 - $2,000,000 = $3,000,000 |
A financial institution claims the tax credit on its Ontario corporate tax return (CT-23).
Questions with respect to this tax legislation bulletin may be directed to:
Ministry of Revenue
Corporations Tax Branch
33 King St. W.
PO Box 622
Oshawa, Ont.
L1H 8H6
Tel: 1 800 263-7965
Questions with respect to outstanding regulations may be directed to:
Ministry of Revenue
Tax Design and Legislation
Branch
2nd floor, Frost Building North
95 Grosvenor Street, Queen's
Park
Toronto, Ontario
M7A 1Z1
Attention: Michael Waterston
Phone: 416 325-2429
Fax: 416 314-8635